I have to admit, I tend to be
naturally sceptical of supplements that are said to help a person lose
weight. I tend to think that we humans are so variable, and different
people respond to different things. What works for one person, may not
work for another. (That said, I came across some very interesting research into the apple cider vinegar and honey diet!).
I also tend to think that, in matters regarding weight loss, there are often a combination of factors at work:
- Diet (and eating habits)
- Physical activity
- Emotional well being
But what if, regardless, you’re interested in bee pollen for weight loss?
Well, as far as I am aware, there is no ‘Bee Pollen Diet’, instead, bee pollen is taken as a supplement to the diet, in various formats. See my page below How To Take Bee Pollen.
But before you do that, let's look at whether bee pollen aids weight loss.
Can you lose weight with bee pollen? In my research, I have not seen any evidence at all that eating bee pollen aids weight loss in humans. I know some people will be annoyed at me for stating this, but I'm sorry, I'm afraid I can find no evidence, and I do not think it fair to promote something I cannot believe in.
what have I learned?
Note that if you want a low carbohydrate diet, bee pollen contains 55% carbohydrate, 30% protein - so bee pollen is not low in carbohydate!
There may be some slight variations depending on the type of
pollen – i.e. pollens vary depending on plant species from where the
bees gathered it. Read more about
nutrition and bee pollen.
Also, do be aware of that some people may experience
side effects from taking bee pollen.
2. Studies in Rats And Mice
Studies are sometimes referred to that took place in rats or mice - although I haven't seen one that conclusively proves that rodents which were fed with bee pollen lost weight, or were permanently slimmer because of it specifically - and certainly, none that compared it with the effect of other diets on rodents - such as a balanced or high fruit and vegetable diet.
Indeed, I have not found any convincing evidence that would show therefore, that taking bee pollen for weight loss would be effective in humans.
Anyway, if it works, why not prove it, by executing a study in humans? I’m sure there would be lots of willing volunteers, and bee pollen is a natural product, after all. I would have thought it would be possible to construct some kind of trial, and the dieting industry would want to get hold of it.
In addition to which, it has been proven that some trials replicated in rats and mice can sometimes produce very different results despite rats and mice both being rodents.
Likewise, what works in a trial on monkeys can have entirely different results in humans. Therefore, unless a quality trial is conducted on humans, I'm afraid I'll reserve judgement. See my point about 'Comparisons with animals' below for further information about some disasters!
One of the reasons I find the apple cider vinegar and honey diet intriguing, however, is because there is trial evidence - in humans!
3. Other Studies
Other animal studies are referred to in some information sources, in particular outlining what might be construed as benefits (not always conclusively though!) – and a reader may infer from these studies that a similar benefit could apply to humans.
For example, I saw information quoting that a study showed how rats and mice can live healthily only on bee pollen – in other words, they ate a bee pollen diet.
Well so what? Some flies can live on excrement! Worms can live on decaying leaves!
This may be true, but no doubt there are other single foods they could live healthily on! But what does it prove? Well, I wouldn’t advise you to convert to a bee pollen diet based on that evidence!
In my mind, it
proves nothing for humans, with our longer life spans, different body
chemistry and biology, and in fact, what dieticians and physicians have
recommended for centuries, is a varied and balanced diet anyway, that
can easily be obtained from every day foods, at good value prices.
4. Comparisons With Animals
Actually, as I stated before, in general, I am also reserved when it comes to making comparisons between humans and animals. Just because something works for animals, does not mean it works in the same way for humans. Let me make my point clearer: when humans rely on animal tests as indicators of what will happen in the human body, results can be disastrous. Just two examples:
Of course, I am not
saying that bee pollen is toxic, merely that if bee pollen for weight
loss works, let’s see some direct evidence on humans, so that we can be
sure of the claims.
5. Just A Nutrient Supplement - Is That All?
Many of the claims about the use of bee pollen in weight loss, are about the replacement of nutrients in the diet, rather than a claim that you can lose weight with bee pollen.
But there are probably cheaper ways to do this, with every day foods, which may also be rich in anti-oxidants, vitamins, minerals and so on (check out my link Bee Pollen Nutrition as it compares the nutritional content of bee pollen with ordinary foods which are cheaply and widely available).
Please note, if you are still contemplating taking bee pollen at all, consider whether you may be susceptible to bee pollen allergy.
Also, please be aware that the FDA has issued some warnings about adulterated bee pollen.
brings me to my next point: with regard to bee pollen & weight
loss, which is: let’s also have some clarity in the message by answering
these two questions:
you thought bee pollen was going to be a miracle cure to enable weight
loss, I do apologise if I have 'burst your bubble', but I feel it is
important to present information to enable people to make informed
choices. I am happy to review my pages if anyone can inform me of a robust trial in humans - do get in touch if you have anything!
COPYRIGHT 2010 - 2018: WWW.BUZZABOUTBEES.NET
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.