Our wild bees (and indeed other pollinators) are hugely important, yet many pollinating species remain unsung heroes of the environment, gardens and countryside.
I campaign for solitary bees, bumble bees and honey bees. Many of the actions we take to protect one pollinator species – whether it be honey bees or wild bees, (such as flower rich habitat creation, protection from pesticides), will assist biodiversity as a whole.
However, I do feel dismayed when I receive comments and criticism for this approach. Why?
Well there are those like me, who can see that all the bees and other pollinators are important. On the other hand, I’ve had people contacting me to say that honey bees are more important than the rest, whilst others insist that wild bees and pollinators would be better off if honey bees were allowed to die out.
Now with regard to the second point, for those who think honey bees are a nuisance and should be allowed to die out, then I suggest you read my page about why honey bees matter (opens new window) for an alternative perspective about this enchanting little pollinator.
I have also written a page about some of the problems faced by wild
insect pollinators (see the link at the bottom of this page). Many
species of moths, butterflies, beetles and so on, are having a very hard
time too, which is bad news, because they all play their own vital role
in the web of life.
This page is written to put the case for
wild bees. In the same way that I have defended honey bees from those
who argue they should be left to die out, on this page, I will counter
the argument that only honey bees matter, whilst wild bees do not. I’ll
use some of the broad-brush statements people have actually made to me
as a basis upon which to address this issue.
And here they are….
"In a colony of honey bees, there may be about 50,000 to 60,000 workers. Because there are so many, they therefore provide greater pollination coverage, and so are far more important than bumble bees and solitary bees".
Honey bees are crucial for pollination services - for example, almond crop in California are entirely dependent on honey bees.
However, efficient pollination of any crop depends on a number of factors, including:
The speed at which the bees work is a key factor. According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture researchers, a study by Bosch and Kemp, 2001 revealed that only 250 female blue orchard bees (Osmia lignaria) are needed to pollinate an acre of apples, that would usually have required the service of one to two honey bee hives, with 15,000 to 20,000 workers in each.
Under the same conditions, bumble bees actually pollinate more flowers per bee than honey bees (from: Bumblebees Behaviour and Ecology; Prof. Dave Goulson; citing Poulson 1973; Free 1993).
In some flowers, pollen is not easily brushed off from anthers onto an insect body.
This means that although an insect may visit a flower to forage on nectar, they will not necessarily pollinate it. Honey bees are unable to ‘buzz pollinate’. Bumble bees manage this by vibrating their flight muscles, thus shaking the pollen from the anthers.
Some flowers require ‘tripping’ in order for pollination to occur. For example, with Alfalfa, two petals hold the stamen which holds the pollen-bearing anthers. When visited by bees, this ‘triggers’ the stamen to spring forth, enabling contact with the bee, and transfer of pollen.
However, this triggering mechanism has been found to discourage honey bees, which, apparently, learn to avoid this triggering by approaching the flower from behind, thus enabling them to gather nectar but not pollen. Other bee species – especially solitary bees of the Megachilidae family, are not put off by the triggering process, and are particularly effective for pollinating alfalfa.
Honey bees have short tongues in comparison with other longer-tongued bees, such as some of the bumble bee species. This means honey bees are not so keen to visit certain deep flowers (Goulson).
Personally, I would simplify this: some bees are specialists whilst others are generalists in the types of flowers they will visit, but even generalist foragers will have their preferred flowers, whilst they leave others alone.
"But honey bees are the primary pollinators for crop pollination, and therefore they are more important".
It is true that honey bees are primarily used in commercial pollination, but this is due to man’s domestication of the species, and lack of knowledge about the importance and sometimes greater efficiency of other pollinators of some crops.
It is also correct that the service of honey bees to agriculture is vitally important.
However, it is also true that increasingly, other bees are being reared for commercial pollination, but this is a relatively recent development (and one I am not so sure I’m keen on!).
As an example, the efficiency of bumble bees in commercial pollination of tomatoes, was not even discovered until the 1980s.
It was discovered
in the Netherlands, where several companies began rearing Bombus terrestris.
Within 3 years, 95% of tomato growers in the Netherlands had switched
to bumblebee pollination. (Source: Bumblebees Behaviour and Ecology;
Prof. Dave Goulson).
"Honey bees are more important, because they provide honey, wax and so on"
I have to say, I think honey bees give and give and give.
I would even add to that list the fact that honey bees have provided much inspiration for humanity, such as the use of hexagons. It is also true that other honey bee products have been exploited by man, such as bee venom, and also honey bee pollen (the supposed advantages of which I remain unconvinced about).
However, some crops are only pollinated by wild bees and other pollinators, and not honey bees. Some of these plants provide important products and/or food for humans.
My point is that all bees are important.
"I read that honey bees pollinate nearly all the wild flowers in the countryside"
Honey bees will certainly pollinate wild flowers, nevertheless, the information you have read is likely to be incorrect.
"Bumble bees get too much attention, because they are cute and fluffy, whereas honey bees should receive more attention"
It’s true, I actually received this message via social media! I attempted to reassure the person that this simply was not the case.
As an example, I conducted a search for ‘honey bees’ in Google at that time, and it produced 2,280,000 results – many of these mentions being from online, mainstream newspaper articles, as well as blogs, campaigns, websites and so on. Even many high profile campaigns by commercial and voluntary organisations tend to focus on honey bees without mentioning wild bees, despite their plight and importance.
Whilst I am keen that
honey bees are helped, it is VERY IMPORTANT to realise that solving
honey bee specific problems, such as varroa, and increasing the number
of beekeepers, does not mean that all is well with our pollinators, but I
fear that many will think this is the case. Indeed, more needs to be
done to raise awareness of the problems faced by wild bees and insect
Meanwhile, I have concerns about the commercialisation of bees. We have already tampered with honey bees over centuries, many would argue, to the desires of man but to the detriment of the honey bees themselves, especially in terms of health.
Mistakes have already been made in the USA, with the shipping around of bumble bees into new locations, and the spread of disease to local species that have not naturally had the time to build up a resistance to the new disease. I think we need to get better informed and re-look at our land management practices, before we develop further risky practices such as this.
"Honey bees are more important because they can be managed"
Increasingly, wild bees are being reared and ‘managed’.
On my page Why Do Honey Bees Matter, I outline how important this is for humans in terms of monitoring environmental stressors.
I cannot stress the importance of this (nor my love for this enchanting little creature) - enough.
However, I believe it is important to remember that whilst honey bees may be managed, the diseases and problems experienced by honey bees, the collapses in populations, combined with the fact that we are becoming more aware (albeit very slowly) of the importance of other pollinators, indicate that is is very unwise to neglect, ignore and allow destructive practices towards other wild bees and pollinators. Relying on only one species for pollination, would seem foolish and detrimental to food and environmental security.
Some people have the habit of viewing life in terms of competition, then transferring those values to wildlife.
But nature can balance itself out beautifully, and I think it’s more helpful for all parties to work together to protect all the species. All of wildlife plays a role – there are no superfluous species, even if we think there are – just our lack of understanding. And again, for those who may feel enraged at my support for wild bees, take a look now at my page about why honey bees matter.
COPYRIGHT 2010 - 2021: WWW.BUZZABOUTBEES.NET
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.