What is the ICPBR?
It is the International Commission For Plant Bee Relationships.
It was founded in 1950, by Anna Maurizio, and briefly, it has the objective to promote and co-ordinate research on the relationships between plants and bees of all types.
The scope of this research includes, for example, studies of insect pollinated plants, bee foraging behaviour, effects of pollinator visits on plants, management and protection of insect pollinators, bee collected materials from plants e.g. nectar and pollen, products derived from plants and modified by bees.
According to their website, the ICPBR has 3 working groups, and these are:
is this latter group, the ‘Bee Protection Group’ that may surprise
many, particularly in view of who sits on this group, and the kinds of
ideas and proposals they generate.
Let us take an
example, and that is, the outcomes of the Bee Protection Working Group
at ICPBR Bee Protection Group Symposium in 2008, which can be downloaded
Firstly, the sponsors of this meeting were:
attended this meeting (that appeared to be called: ‘The Hazard of
Pesticides to Bees’)? – a list of the delegates can be found
here (opens new window).
You will note that almost all of them are conspicuously agrochemical industry representatives, or those who in some capacity, are employed by them, such as on a research consultancy basis, helping agchem get marketing authorisations for their pesticides, for example.
were also Civil Servants in attendance, such as Helen Thompson and
Selwyn Jenkins, UK civil servant working for FERA, the UK Food And
Environment Research Agency.
Note that at the end of 2008, Helen Thompson, certainly had the role of Secretary of the ICPBR Bee Protection Group)(1).
servants are of course, meant to serve the good of the people and
environment who they ultimately are supposed to work for.
Two papers were produced which can be downloaded
Proposed revision of the higher tier testing requirements for EPPO Standard PP1/170: Test methods for evaluating the side-effects of plant protection products on honeybees
Gavin Lewis*, Mike Coulson, Christine Vergnet, Christian Maus, Helen M Thompson, Roland Becker, Dick Rogers, Ingo Tornier
Christian Maus - Bayer Crop Science
Mike Coulson - Zeneca- Agrochemicals
Roland Becker - BASF Agrochemicals
Dick Rogers, believed now to be with Bayer CropScience. Previous job: Wildwood Labs Inc.
Tornier -Eurofins GAB - consultants for the Agrochem industry who help
agro chem companies gain registrations for pesticides
Lewis - JSC International Ltd – appear to be consultants for the
Agrochem industry who help companies gain registrations – Vice Chair
And the second paper:
Proposal of the ICPBR Bee Brood Group for testing and assessing potential side effects from the use of plant protection products on honey bee brood
It is written by:
Roland Becker (BASF), Christine Vergnet (AFSSA), Christian Maus (Bayer Crop Science), Jens Pistorius (JKI), Ingo Tornier (Eurofins GAB), Selwyn Wilkins (Fera)
(This paper mentions ‘Bee Brood Group’ – the paper is produced under the ‘Bee Protection Group’ heading).
Who are the names on this paper?
are all industry names apart from Wilkins and Vergnet, who are civil
servants. Most of the authors’ allegiances are clear, but for further
Vergnet - The French Agency for Environmental and Occupational Health
Safety – appears to be a civil servant like Helen Thompson.
More recently, a leaflet: : http://www.ecrgroup.eu/download/bees.pdf -
Gavin Lewis in his role as Vice Chair of the ICPBR – but no mention of
his employment with JSC International Ltd on that leaflet).
Firstly, the public and conservationists may be deeply concerned to see the attempts of industry to influence regulation.
Not only that, perhaps they would be surprised that the members of the pesticides industry (nowadays, calling itself the ‘Plant Protection Industry’) were so prevalent within this 'Bee Protection Group'. Many may feel this is an example of the ‘Fox guarding the chicken coup’.
Read more about the ICPBR Bee Protection Group - what do Beekeepers and Pressure Groups say?
CLICK FOR NEXT PAGE
(1) See foot noteshttps://secure.fera.defra.gov.uk/beebase/downloadNews.cfm?id=47
COPYRIGHT 2010 - 2016: WWW.BUZZABOUTBEES.NET
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.